Guide

Cellular vs satellite ranch monitoring: what works where there is no cell service

What cellular and satellite monitoring each need, how often each reports, and how one water tank monitor uses both so a tank with no cell service still reports.
Satellite coverage map for the GPS ear tags
Between tank readings on cellular
2 hrs
Between tank readings on satellite
6 hrs
Settings to change when the network switches
0
Service price on either network
Same

The short answer

For water tanks you do not have to choose. The VitaRanch water tank monitor carries a cellular radio and a satellite radio in one unit, detects which network it can reach, and uses it. The GPS ear tags are simpler: they use satellite only, everywhere.

The rest of this guide explains what each network needs, what you get from each, and what that means for a tank at the house and a tank on the back side of the lease.

How cellular monitoring works, and where it stops

A cellular monitor sends its readings through the same towers your phone uses. It is quick and it can report often. Its limit is simple: it needs signal at the device. Signal at the house does not help a tank three pastures away, and a monitor that only has a cellular radio goes quiet when the signal does.

The VitaRanch water tank monitor uses 4G LTE Cat-M1 when cellular is available, and on cellular it reports every 2 hours, which is 12 readings a day.

How satellite monitoring works, and what it needs

A satellite monitor sends its readings straight up. It needs no towers, gateways or WiFi, so it works past the end of cell coverage. It needs one thing instead: a clear view of the sky. Metal roofs, metal buildings and heavy tree cover get in the way.

Satellite reports are spaced through the day. On satellite the water tank monitor reports every 6 hours, which is 4 readings a day, and the GPS ear tags report a position every 6 hours.

Side by side

Cellular and satellite compared for VitaRanch devices
CellularSatellite
What it needsCell signal at the deviceA clear view of the sky
Water tank monitor reportsEvery 2 hours (12 a day)Every 6 hours (4 a day)
GPS ear tagsNot usedEvery 6 hours
Who picks the networkThe monitor, automaticallyThe monitor, automatically
Alerts and appThe sameThe same
Service price for a tankThe sameThe same

One monitor, both networks

Here is what the water tank monitor does on its own:

  • Cell signal available: it reports over cellular, 12 times a day.
  • No cell signal: it switches to satellite, 4 reports a day.
  • Signal comes back: it switches back to cellular.

You never drive out to change a mode. Put the monitor where you need it, on the edge of town or the back side of the lease, and it finds a way to report. The dashboard shows whether each sensor is currently using cellular or satellite.

Is four readings a day enough?

A tank on satellite updates less often than one on cellular. That is normal, and four readings a day is plenty to catch a tank that is dropping. What matters more than the count is where you set your alert levels: set the warning level high enough to cover the time it takes you to get there and how fast that tank drops on a hot day.

There is more on levels and on reading the chart in stock tank water level monitoring.

Mounting so both networks work

  • Give the module a wide-open view of the sky.
  • Do not mount it under a metal roof, carport or lean-to, inside a metal shed or barn, or under heavy tree cover.
  • Mount it on a sturdy post, fence or wall, high enough that cattle cannot rub, lick or butt it.

Why the ear tags are satellite only

Cattle do not stay where the signal is. The GPS ear tags skip cellular entirely and report straight to satellite, so a tag works the same in the pasture by the house and in a canyon three hours from pavement. The tags are solar powered, and there is nothing to set up on the ranch. See GPS ear tags for cattle: how they work and what they cost.

What it costs either way

You do not pay more for a tank that ends up on satellite. The water tank monitor is $350.00, the first year of service is included, and after that service is $100 per tank per year whichever network the tank uses. Each cattle ear tag is $220.22 with 3 years of satellite service included, then $10 per tag per year.

Satellite Water Tank Monitor

Cellular and satellite in one unit. It picks the network on its own.

See the product